Looking for Wisconsin gifts under $25? Shop local this holiday season with our guide to 14 budget-friendly gifts from Wisconsin makers and businesses.
The holiday shopping season is officially here, and while it’s easy to default to the big online retailers, there’s nothing quite like gifting something made right here in Wisconsin. The best part? Supporting our local independent makers and small businesses doesn’t have to break the bank. From small-batch pantry staples to wearable art, here are 14 of my favorite local gift ideas—all coming in at $25 or under—to get you started.
For the foodie
Wisconsin cheese

Let’s get this one out of the way right off the bat. We couldn’t make a list of Wisconsin-made gifts without including cheese. If you have someone on your list who is also a fan of all things dairy, a few blocks of Wisconsin cheese are sure to be a hit.
There is a plethora of places to buy great cheese in the state. You can buy it straight from a local factory like Henning Cheese in Kiel. There, you can easily get a handful of top flavors for under $25. You can also go check out a specialty shop like the Cheese Counter in Plymouth or simply visit your local grocery store.
Popcorn
Another foodie favorite is bound to be some local popcorn. While Wisconsin cheese is an easy win, our popcorn is pretty good too. You can find homemade popcorn at lots of local spots, with flavors ranging from classics like caramel and cheddar to more location-specific ones like Broadway Popcorn’s specialty Cherry Chocolate Cheesecake.
While places like Broadway Popcorn allow you to order online, gifting popcorn is a great excuse to go to the shop in person and do a little sampling. At Broadway, small bags of popcorn start at around $6.25, so you can get a variety for under $25.
A gift card to a local restaurant
Treat the foodie on your list to some food from their favorite restaurant. Whether they love Friday fish fry or can’t say no to a cheese curd appetizer, this gift will surely hit the mark. The best part about buying a restaurant gift card—you have the perfect excuse to dine out, too.
For the spirited sipper
Craft beer

Like cheese, I would be remiss not to include beer on this list. A variety pack of craft beer from your local brewery can make a great gift for the right person. Breweries, like O’so Brewing Company, allow you to build your own 6-pack, which can be fun and also a great test of how well you know the person you are gifting it to.
You can also go for some reliable Wisconsin staples like a pack of New Glarus Brewing’s Spotted Cow or opt for a cool piece of merch, like a pint glass from their favorite taproom. If the person on your list doesn’t drink alcohol, no problem! Many breweries in Wisconsin (e.g., 3 Sheeps Brewing) now offer craft non-alcoholic beer or soda. Root beer, anyone?
Door County wine
If your giftee is like me, then beer might not be their drink of choice. Blasphemous, I know. But Wisconsin doesn’t just do beer. It also has some great wineries, especially in and around Door County. This past summer I visited Wisconsin’s oldest licensed winery, Von Stiehl Winery in Algoma. After doing a tasting, I walked out with bottles of its Peach Moscato ($13.99) and Naughty Girl White ($16.99).
Another Wisconsin favorite is wine from Door Peninsula Winery. The original winery was located in an old two-room schoolhouse in Carlsville. Today, the location has expanded several times due to demand. Two of its best-selling wines and my personal favorites are Blackberry Merlot and Sunset Splash, which both start at $13.99 per bottle.
For the home chef
Spices
I am so happy that Wisconsin is home to Penzeys Spices. While it has expanded to other states, its roots will always be here. I’m a huge fan of Penzeys, and chances are your home chef will be too—or at least, they will be very soon.
Penzeys offers spices to suit a variety of cooking styles and cuisines. A few of my favorite products that I always have on hand include Smoked Spanish Paprika, Sunny Paris Seasoning, and the Green Goddess Dressing Base. If you are not sure what to get, you can’t go wrong with a gift box. They often go on sale, and some are regularly priced under $25, like the Mini Soul Box or Joy of Cinnamon Mini Gift Box.
Maple syrup
The Sugar Maple is Wisconsin’s state tree. Consequently, many of us have an affinity for maple syrup. Yes, it’s a must-have on your pancakes and waffles, but you’d be surprised how versatile it can be as an ingredient in other dishes.
You can buy locally tapped syrup from shops and sellers across the state. One standout example is Tapped Maple Syrup in Stevens Point, which is known in part for its infused maple syrups, perfect for your experimental chef. Aren’t you at least a little curious how they might use Black Umami Garlic Infused Maple Syrup?
Wisconsin cookbook
Cooks and cookbooks go hand in hand, so you can’t go wrong with gifting one to the home chef in your life, especially if it’s written by a fellow Wisconsinite, like “The Wisconsin Cheese Cookbook” by Kristine Hansen. When you go to pick out your cookbook, try to support a local bookstore. If you’d rather shop online, check out Bookshop.org, which allows you to directly support a favorite bookstore of your choice.
For the comfort connoisseur
Soy candles

I don’t think anything is cozier than a candle. It’s one of those items that most people enjoy and use, making it a safe bet for gifting. Wisconsin has a variety of companies and small local makers who specialize in candles. One example is Sconnie Candle Co., which is known for its hand-poured soy candles in a variety of Wisconsin-inspired scents, including Door County Cherry Wine and Supper Club.
A cup of coffee
Nothing says cozy morning comfort like a cup of coffee. Whether the person on your list prefers to drink theirs at home or at their local coffee shop, there’s a gift for them. For the homebodies, you can’t go wrong with Door County Coffee. You can find it at its primary location in Sturgeon Bay and in stores across the state. Its single-serve cups typically start around $11 per box, and its 8-ounce bags around $10. Not a coffee drinker? They also offer hot cocoa at around $9 per tin.
Another option: give a gift card to a favorite local coffee spot. Pretty much every town in Wisconsin has one. I’ve lived in three cities in Wisconsin. Here’s my favorite local spot in each to get you started: Zest Bakery and Coffeehouse in Stevens Point, Chiffon Boutique & Bakery in New Holstein, and Whisk & Arrow Sugar Studio in Appleton.
Handmade lotions and lip balms

Another one of my personal favorite products is the lip balm from Olivü 426. It starts at $3.50 per tube and is made using minimal ingredients. The original uses two: olive oil and beeswax. Over the years, the product line has expanded; you can get balms with SPF, color tint, and a variety of different flavors. If you go to their store in Sheboygan, you can even make your own custom product. They also offer a variety of other products, from haircare to skincare, bath and body, and home.
For the everyday eclectic
A print from a Wisconsin artist

While original paintings are often more expensive than $25—and rightfully so—you can still support a local artist and get a unique piece by buying a print. Recently, I attended an art show in Wausau and bought a print by Pete Sandker. His watercolors capture subjects in nature. But his style is unique in that it is kind of like looking at a picture within a picture. Every time you take a look, you see some new detail. His 5×7 prints start at $20 and would make an excellent gift.
If his work isn’t quite the style you are going for, that’s okay. Check out a local gallery or artist collective near you. Chances are, you’ll be able to find a print for under $25 that fits your vibe perfectly.
Locally designed clothes
There are creators across Wisconsin who design their own screen-printed or embroidered clothes. These unique creations can make a great gift for those who aren’t afraid of a little whimsy. One standout creator based in Milwaukee specializes in embroidered designs. The shop is called Sun Milk, and I am in love with the Cow Hat ($25) and the Strawberry Fields Boxy Tee ($25). Both are definitely going on my holiday wish list this year.
Handcrafted jewelry
Like clothes, jewelry is a form of wearable art and is often a hit when gifted to the right person. You can find handcrafted Wisconsin-made jewelry across the state at local boutiques, shops, craft fairs, and art studios.
One of my favorite creators, Lil Petunia, makes earrings from polymer clay. I met her about five years ago at a holiday craft fair in Kiel. She inspired me to start making my own, and every year, I look for her at that event. It’s been great getting to see her progression. But I digress; the point is, there are so many talented people like Lil Petunia in your own community that you can support this holiday season.



